Which Australian broker has the lowest spreads?
Both advertise 0.0 pips on their raw accounts, and both figures are minimums — the tightest price ever quoted, typically during the London and New York overlap. Neither tells you what you pay on a Tuesday afternoon in Sydney or during an RBA decision.
Why we have not printed IC Markets’ averages as fact. Three problems, all on IC’s own Australian domain. Its table shows a Raw EUR/USD average of 0.01 while four other pages on the same site claim 0.1. Its Standard row shows a minimum of 0.8 and an average of 0.1 — an average cannot be lower than the minimum. And its help centre states the gold average is 1 pip against a table value of 0.09. No measurement window appears anywhere. These are not small discrepancies; they are the difference between a published figure and a checkable one.
And Pepperstone’s gap. It publishes no Australian average spreads at all, and its one commodity average — 0.22 on gold — comes from a legal PDF with a July 2025 window, now thirteen months old, in which the PDF and website disagree on the minimum (0.1 against 0.08).
Table 1 — Published spreads
| Pepperstone | IC Markets | |
|---|---|---|
| EUR/USD minimum | Razor 0.0 · Standard 1.0 | Raw 0.0 · Standard 0.8 |
| EUR/USD average | Not published for Australia | Published, but see the warning below |
| Gold minimum | Razor 0.08 · Standard 0.15 | Raw 0.05 · Standard 0.1 |
| Gold average | 0.22 — from a PDF, window July 2025 | 0.09, undated |
| Measurement period stated? | No | No |
So compare the commission instead
This is the part both firms publish clearly, and it is where the difference actually sits.
Note what happens on a USD account. Both charge USD 7.00 round turn — identical. The AUD gap exists because IC prices its AUD commission at 4.50 a side rather than converting its USD rate. If you fund in Australian dollars, you pay the difference; if you fund in USD, you do not. That single choice at signup is worth AUD 600 a year at 25 lots a month.
Table 2 — Commission on raw accounts
| Platform | Pepperstone | IC Markets |
|---|---|---|
| MT4 / MT5, AUD account | AUD 3.50 per side — AUD 7.00 round turn | AUD 4.50 per side — AUD 9.00 round turn |
| MT4 / MT5, USD account | USD 7.00 round turn | USD 7.00 round turn |
| Gold, AUD account | AUD 4.50 per side (MT5) — AUD 9.00 | Charged as FX — AUD 9.00 |
| cTrader | USD 6.00 round turn, fixed per lot | USD 3.00 per side per USD 100,000 traded |
| TradingView | USD 7.00 round turn | Via cTrader pricing |