Which UK trading platform is best?
It depends entirely on which of two jobs you are doing, and they are not close to the same job.
If you are buying shares and funds to hold — in an ISA, a pension or a general account — you want low custody fees, cheap dealing and a wrapper that suits your balance. Cost is dominated by the annual percentage, not the per-trade charge.
If you are trading actively — leveraged positions, short holding periods — you want tight spreads, low commission and fast execution. Cost is dominated by per-trade charges, and the platform fee is usually zero.
The mistake that costs the most is using a CFD account to hold a long-term position. Overnight financing accrues daily and will quietly exceed any dealing commission you saved within months. If you intend to own something for a year, own it — do not rent it with leverage.
Platform and custody fees compared
A correction worth making, because it is widely reported the other way round. Hargreaves Lansdown’s share cap is not different between ISA and SIPP — three of its own pages agree it is £12.50 a month in all three wrappers. AJ Bell is the one with differing caps: £3.50 on a dealing account or ISA against £10 on a SIPP.
The cap is what decides this for a larger portfolio. On £100,000 of shares, an uncapped 0.45% would be £450 a year; capped at £12.50 a month it is £150. On funds, where AJ Bell tiers rather than caps, the arithmetic runs differently again — and above £500,000 in funds AJ Bell charges nothing at all.
Table 1 — Custody and platform fees
| Platform | Share custody fee | Cap | Fund custody fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading 212 | Free | — | Free |
| Hargreaves Lansdown | 0.45% | £12.50/month — same across Fund & Share, ISA and SIPP | Tiered from 0.45% |
| AJ Bell | 0.25% | £3.50/month dealing account and ISA · £10/month SIPP | 0.25% to £250k · 0.10% £250k–£500k · nil above £500k |
Dealing commission
Two things are doing the work in that table. The frequent-dealer discount — both HL and AJ Bell drop their commission sharply once you cross a monthly deal count, and HL waives it entirely for regular monthly investing. And the conversion fee, which for anyone buying US shares from a GBP account is usually the larger number.
Compare 0.15% against 0.75% on a £20,000 US position. Trading 212 charges about £30 to convert; eToro charges about £150 — and charges again on the way out, and again on every dividend. Neither appears in a headline commission table, and over a decade the difference dwarfs the dealing charges people actually compare.
Table 2 — Dealing commission and conversion
| Platform | UK shares | US shares | FX conversion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading 212 | Free | Free | 0.15% |
| eToro | $1 or $2 per side | $1 or $2 per side | 0.75%, including on dividends |
| Hargreaves Lansdown | £6.95 (0–19 deals last month) · £3.95 (20+) · free by monthly Direct Debit · £29 by phone | Same online tariff plus FX | Tiered |
| AJ Bell | £5.00 online · £3.50 if 10+ deals last month · £25 by phone | £5.00 online · £25 by phone | 0.75% first £10k · 0.50% next £10k · 0.25% above £20k · dividends 0.50% |